5 Reasons WhatsApp vs Signal Security Comparison Best

 

I remember when someone first recommended the Signal app to me, my first question was: "Who wins in the WhatsApp vs Signal security comparison?" Since then I tested both apps, and here I am sharing an honest, real-life comparison with you.

 

Let's start a one-on-one competition!

 

💬 End-to-End Encryption – Base Level of Both

WhatsApp and Signal both use end-to-end encryption, which means that the message between you and the receiver cannot be seen by any third person.

 

✅ WhatsApp uses the Signal Protocol, which is open-source and highly trusted.

 

✅ Signal: Uses its own Signal Protocol at the core level — and ironically, WhatsApp is also based on this protocol.

 

I think Signal is a little more transparent than encryption.

 

🔍 Metadata Collection – Who keeps how much information?

You will notice that when it comes to privacy, it is not enough to just secure messages, but metadata is also important (like who is talking to whom, when and for how long).

 

📱 WhatsApp collects:

 

Contact list

 

Location (if allowed)

 

Device info

 

Usage patterns

 

📵 Signal collects:

 

Only user phone number

 

No contact list access

 

No usage tracking

 

Result: Signal is clearly the winner in this category — because it literally doesn’t collect any unnecessary data.

 

🔔 Notification Privacy – Safety even on lock screen

 

WhatsApp automatically displays message previews in notifications, unless you disable it.

 

In Signal, you can custom it to just show “New message” or not show the sender’s name.

 

I personally find Signal’s notification style more secure — especially when you use the phone in a public place.

 

🧠 App Permissions – What access does it ask for?

 

Don’t ignore permissions. When you install an app, it asks you for camera, mic, location access.

 

📲 WhatsApp:

 

Camera

 

Microphone

 

Contacts

 

Files

 

Location (optional)

 

🔐 Signal:

 

Contacts (but doesn’t save them)

 

Camera/Mic (only when needed)

 

Signal asks for minimal permissions — and I find this to be the best feature for privacy-conscious people.

 

🧾 Chat Backup – In the cloud or local?

This is where the game changes.

 

💥 WhatsApp:

 

Chat backup is done in Google Drive (Android) or iCloud (iPhone).

 

Backup is not encrypted by default (encryption is now optional).

 

🛡️ Signal:

 

Backup is only local.

 

The encryption key is with the user.

 

No data is on the cloud.

 

Imagine if someone hacked your Google account, they could still get your WhatsApp chats. Signal is safer.

 

📞 Voice & Video Call Security – Interception Possible?

 

WhatsApp and Signal both encrypt voice/video calls.

 

But the difference is this:

 

WhatsApp calls go through Facebook servers.

 

Signal employs peer-to-peer whenever possible to minimize exposure.

 

Opinion: Signal calls are slightly more private, especially when you talk about confidential things.

 

🧰 Features and Usability – Secure but Friendly?

WhatsApp:

 

Status, Stories, Stickers, Business tools

 

More user-friendly

 

Most people already use it

 

Signal:

 

Focused on privacy

 

Basic UI

 

Option to create stickers

 

No status feature

 

I like WhatsApp's usability better, but Signal has fewer distractions — which I personally prefer when it comes to secure conversations.

 

💻 Open Source Advantage – Is the code hidden or not?

 

Signal is 100% open source – this means developers can check its code.

 

WhatsApp is partially open source, although Facebook/Meta does not publish the core code.

 

For privacy geeks, Signal is far more transparent.

 

🛡️ Group Privacy & Admin Controls

WhatsApp:

 

You can be added to any group without approval (change privacy)

 

Signal:

 

Group invitation link is mandatory

 

Privacy settings are strict

 

Imagine if you have been added to an unknown group — Signal protects you from this situation.

 

🔄 Updates & Trust Factor – How Transparent is it?

WhatsApp:

 

Owned by Meta (Facebook)

 

Past privacy issues (Cambridge Analytica scandal etc.)

 

Signal:

 

Independent, non-profit organization

 

Funded through donations

 

I think Signal has a higher trust level, as it does not have a commercial ad-based business model behind it.

 

⚖️ Summary – WhatsApp vs Signal Security Comparison

Feature	WhatsApp	Signal
Metadata Collection	High	Extremely Low
End-to-End Encryption	Yes	Yes (same protocol)
Chat Backup	Cloud (less secure)	Local (encrypted)
Permissions	More	Minimal
Open Source	Partially	Fully
Notifications	Standard	Privacy-Friendly
Group Privacy	Weak	Strong
Owner	Meta	Independent
Voice/Video Call Privacy	Good	Better

 If you want more beginner-friendly tech guides, be sure to visit our home page for more informative articles.

🔚 Final Thoughts – Which App to Choose?

If you are a user who needs convenience, wants to be in contact with more people, and also has to run a business, then WhatsApp can be a better choice.

 

But if whether you are a privacy enthusiast, a journalist, or just want secure communication — Signal is the gold standard app.

 

I personally have experience with both apps, but whenever there is a sensitive or private matter — I use Signal.

 

You also try and decide which app you feel more trust in.

❔ FAQs – WhatsApp vs Signal Security Comparison

Q1: Are both WhatsApp and Signal encrypted?

Yes, both apps use end-to-end encryption—but Signal is more transparent.

Q2: Is Signal free?

Absolutely. Signal is 100% free and does not use any ads or tracking.

Q3: Is WhatsApp backup safe?

If you don't enable encryption, WhatsApp backups are not secure in the cloud.

Q4: Is Signal difficult to use?

No, Signal's interface is simple. It's just a little different from WhatsApp.

Q5: Which app gives you more control over privacy settings?

In Signal, you get more detailed controls — especially in group and notification privacy.